jump to navigation

The Holy Spirit is a popular theme August 16, 2007

Posted by roberttalley in Acts, Baptism of the Holy Spirit, Charismatic Movement, First Corinthians, Holy Spirit, Pentecostalism, Religion, Sermons, Tongues.

From Latrese “…I have one question that is really burning within me. What are your views on ’speaking in tongues’ and the ‘baptism of the Holy Spirit’? I know people who do this, but I never have. When I prayed ‘the prayer’ to receive this, nothing happened. Is this another false doctrine? If so, then what are the ‘tongues’ that these people I know are speaking?”

There are whole books written on this subject but I will try to be as brief as possible. You can then respond to whichever of my comments you desire and we can go from there if you wish.

Speaking in tongues occurs three times in the book of Acts and is a major part of the discussion of spiritual gifts in 1 Corinthians 12-14. On the day of Pentecost, we know that speaking in tongues referred to known languages and there is no overriding reason in any of the other places to assure us that it was otherwise although there is much debate about the Corinthian passage. The purpose of tongues in Acts at Pentecost was to confirm the message the apostles were preaching (which is why the prophecy in Joel is quoted). Later, Cornelius and the Gentiles with him spoke in tongues for the purpose of confirming that the message of Jesus Christ was for both Jew and Gentile. The third time seems to be a confirmation that Jesus Christ was the fulfillment of the gospel of John the Baptist.

The use and purpose of tongues in Corinth is not totally clear although there were clearly abuses in its practice. For one, it was not being used to edify others but rather to edify one’s self which is against the purpose of spiritual gifts. For another, tongues as well as other spiritual gifts were being practiced in the absence of love for the brethren.

There is no command to speak in tongues and it is debatable whether the gift as practiced in the book of Acts exists today. I myself do not believe it exists. If it does not exist today, then the tongues being spoken are most likely emotionalism or fakery. Tongues are not and have never been a general sign of salvation, sanctification, or spirituality.

The baptism of the Holy Spirit first occurred at Pentecost. It was at this time that the church first began to function with the Holy Spirit indwelling and empowering them. In 1 Corinthians 12:13 the baptism of the Holy Spirit is mentioned as the way in which each believer becomes a part of the body of Christ. The baptism at Pentecost and the baptism in 1 Corinthians 12 are one and the same. It does not require nor automatically produce speaking in tongues. (Here is a link to a sermon I preached last fall on the subject “Baptism By the Holy Spirit”).

Is speaking in tongues in connection with the baptism of the Holy Spirit a false doctrine? First, I should point out that not everyone who believes tongues is possible connect it with the baptism of the Holy Spirit. There are many though who believe that speaking in tongues is proof that one has been baptized with the Holy Spirit. They often believe that this is an evidence of salvation. This is false doctrine. It causes people to look for an experience that is not commanded and many fall into the trap of believing they are not saved or cannot be saved unless they have this experience. In this sense, this false doctrine is similar to the Galatian error where it was taught that salvation came through trusting Christ plus circumcision. Paul was pretty severe in his condemnation of those who taught this doctrine (calling it “another gospel”) when he said in Galatians 1, “…let him be accursed” who preaches this gospel. In other words, those who teach that salvation is through faith in Christ plus speaking in tongues are teaching a false gospel and according to Paul are false prophets.

This is a long answer and I have referred to little Scripture in order to keep it short. Please feel free to respond and we can go into more detail.

Here is a sermon from Ray Pritchard directly dealing with speaking in tongues.


1. Father Don - August 16, 2007

As a psychologist and scientist, I have always liked the empirical approach to my spirituality. Did the experience take me closer to Jesus? Did my experience result in a Book of Acts life? etc.
Speaking in tongues changed my entire life and so I hate for people to miss out here. I have discussed this on my blog:

2. roberttalley - August 17, 2007

Thanks, Don, for your comment. Could you more precisely define what you mean by “take me closer to Jesus” or “a Book of Acts life”?

3. Oxysmoron - August 17, 2007

Mr. Talley,

enjoyed reading what you have posted here on this subject…

speaking in tongues and being saved… whether the two are enjoined or whether or not you need one over the other to be saved.

sang in a tongue, interpreted also, yet I know those who do and who have not been given the gift… for not all speak in tongues; otherwise the word of God would not have spoken of other gifts. too, love the thought for which is mentioned… all gifts are given without repentence and Bless the Lord for doing so. Amazes me tho to think people still believe God’s most important Gift would be guarranteed through an outward sign of speaking in tongues. I will take Fruit of the Spirit as my indicator, change of heart, and the renewal of the mind and too allowing God to show forth His own without any outward evidence shown in gifts or talents. bless you Pastor… your site is one of learning.

4. roberttalley - August 17, 2007


Thanks for your kind comments. I agree with the indicators that you have mentioned because they are the ones that I find in the New Testament. Salvation results in a change of character. Perfection? No, that comes when we are with our Lord but there is a definite inner change that naturally has outward effects.

5. Nikos - September 16, 2007

Speaking in Tongues changed my life. I will never be the same again. To say I prayed for it and did not get it is an excuse. I have prayed for many things I did not get but by persisting in prayer in God’s time received it. I encourage everyone to keep on praying and in time you will receive. Be sure to offer to God a holy vessel for Him to fill.

6. roberttalley - September 17, 2007

Hello Nikos!

As I asked Don in the comments above, I would like to ask you also, “In what way did speaking in tongues change your life?”

7. craig b - February 24, 2008

Here is a article I wrote about the value of tongues,

The interesting thing about tongues is that Paul said he spoke in them more than any one else did and not to forbid the gift….If he found it a good gift to have…also we have to have the perspective…its not what we think of it, if it is a gift from God it has to be a good gift…

Have a read and tell me what you think

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: